Family Guide

Scattering by Hand or a Water-Soluble Urn: Choosing Your Way

A plain guide to the two accepted ways to release cremated remains at sea off San Diego, scattering by hand or placing a water-soluble urn.

Burials at Sea San Diego · Published November 2026

When a family plans a burial at sea, one practical question usually comes up early: how will the ashes actually go into the water? There are two accepted ways. The first is to scatter the cremated remains directly from their container at the rail. The second is to place a biodegradable, water-soluble urn on the surface and let the sea take it. Both are dignified and both are common. Neither is more correct than the other. This guide explains what each looks like aboard JADA, the rules that apply to both, and how families can think through the choice.

Scattering by hand at the lee rail

Scattering means opening the container and pouring the cremated remains out over the water. Aboard JADA this happens at the lee rail, the downwind side of the boat. Before the moment arrives, the crew shows the family which side that is, so the ashes carry away from the boat and out over the water instead of back toward the people at the rail.

Scattering is simple and immediate. There is nothing to assemble and nothing to wait for. One person may pour, or the family may decide that several people will each take part. The release itself is brief. For more on the practical side of holding the container and pouring, see Handling Cremated Remains at the Rail.

Placing a water-soluble urn

A water-soluble urn is made of a biodegradable material. Common types are made of paper, salt, sand or gelatin. The cremated remains go inside, and the urn is placed gently on the surface of the water. It floats briefly, then sinks and dissolves. Some designs float for several minutes before they go under.

A soluble urn offers two things that scattering does not. It gives a single, visible moment that everyone aboard can watch together. It also keeps the remains together as they enter the sea, instead of spreading them across the surface. For a closer look at the materials and how the different types behave, see Choosing an Urn for a Burial at Sea.

What the rules require for either way

The same rules apply whichever method a family chooses. Under the EPA general permit for burial at sea, 40 CFR 229.1, issued under the Marine Protection, Research, and Sanctuaries Act, cremated remains may be placed in the ocean at any depth, provided the site is at least three nautical miles from land. Anything placed in the water must be made of materials that readily decompose in the marine environment. In practice, this means plastic and metal urns may not be placed in the water. A family who wants to keep a metal or stone urn can bring the remains in it, scatter from it, and take the urn home afterward. The EPA explains the rule on its burial at sea page, and the full rule text is in the Electronic Code of Federal Regulations.

California has its own rule as well. Health and Safety Code section 7117 allows cremated remains to be scattered at sea at least 500 yards from shore. It requires the person scattering to have the permit for disposition and to file it with the county afterwards. The family brings the permit and the remains to the marina, and the crew records the permit with San Diego County vital records on the family's behalf. Federal rules also require that the EPA be notified within 30 days after a burial at sea. None of these requirements change with the method. They are the same for scattering by hand and for a soluble urn. For the full sequence, see The Paperwork Timeline: From Permit to EPA Filing.

Weighing the choice

Families who are unsure can compare the two side by side:

Some families decide by thinking about the person they are remembering and what would have suited them. Others think about who will be standing at the rail, and whether a quiet, shared moment of watching matters more than the simplicity of pouring. Both lines of thought are reasonable, and there is no wrong answer.

Flowers with either method

Flowers and petals can accompany either choice. Petals can follow the ashes as they are scattered, or be placed on the water around a floating urn. The EPA rule applies to flowers in the same way it applies to urns: they must be made of materials that readily decompose, so no wire and no plastic. More on what works well on the water is in Flowers for a Burial at Sea.

Deciding on the day

A family does not have to settle this weeks ahead. The decision can be made on the day itself, even at sea. Whichever way the remains are released, the crew can follow with a figure-eight pass around the release site and eight bells to close the ceremony, and the family receives a signed certificate with the GPS coordinates of the release. The meaning of the pass is explained in The Meaning of the Figure-Eight After an Ash Scattering.

Rules on burial at sea can change. Before the ceremony, families should check the current requirements with the sources named here: the EPA burial at sea page, California Health and Safety Code section 7117, and the San Diego County Vital Records office. At Burials at Sea San Diego, we are happy to walk you through each step, from the permit to the moment at the rail. When you are ready, you can reserve a date or call (619) 986-7344, and we will help you choose the way that feels right.

← Back to all guides

Reserve a date →